The 10 Emotional Stages of “No Response” E-Mail Rejection

Have you sent an important e-mail to someone recently and are still waiting for that person to e-mail you back? Has it been over 3 days since you sent the e-mail? It was probably a question about a business relationship, job application, coffee meeting, or a request to get press for your company.

But, still no reply. Weird, right?

You probably made up excuses about why that person hasn’t emailed you back:

“She’s a busy person. She’s probably running across town as we speak going from meeting to meeting.”

“He probably has it starred in his e-mail and is waiting to get 20 minutes of relaxation so he can sit down and respond back to me.”

“He probably forwarded it to someone else, and that person hasn’t responded back yet.”

Let me clue you in. That person already replied back to you, and the answer is NO.

Except the response isn’t in your inbox or stuck in your SPAM folder. The lack of a response was the response.

Here is what that person told you, without ever speaking a word or lifting a finger.

No, I don’t want to get coffee with you.
No, I don’t want to write about you on my blog.
No, I cannot connect you with that person.
No, you are not a fit for this job position.

Here are the 10 emotional stages of e-mail rejection:

  1. Excitement – Send an important email to the person you are looking to connect with.
  2. Anxiety – Constant refreshing of your e-mail for the first 5 hours.
  3. Curiosity –  Wondering why they haven’t responded back yet.
  4. Investigation – Checking your spam folder to see if it’s in SPAM.
  5. Confusion – You start questioning your contents of the e-mail. Maybe it was too long or too short? Maybe they didn’t like you when you first met them? Why has that person not responded back yet?
  6. Sadness – Be honest, it’s a little dejecting to send an important email and not get a response.
  7. Anger – Why hasn’t that person responded back? How unprofessional of them. If they wanted to say no, all they had to do was say NO. That person doesn’t know what they’re missing out on.
  8. Acceptance – You have come to acceptance with the person not e-mailing you back. It is what it is.
  9. Lack of Acceptance- Okay, so you haven’t truly accepted it yet. They were probably busy and lost track of the e-mail you sent. So you send another follow up e-mail with a different approach.
  10. Repeat – Go to step 2 and start the process over again.

I have been on both ends of the response-less email transaction, and I’m not sure how I feel about it. On one hand, I wish people would give everyone an ounce of respect for what they are doing and just reply back with an honest answer.

On the other hand, for the people who get these requests all the time, I can understand where they are coming from. If they respond back to the e-mail, it’s just going to lead to another email and the vicious cycle continues. It’s not that they don’t respect the person who emailed them, it’s just that they also need to respect their own time and top priorities.

I’ve learn to accept “NO” responses and move on.

How do you avoid the pain of “No Response” rejection?

The answer to getting a better reply rate to your e-mails is to send an e-mail that offers something that clearly only benefits them. It’s about providing genuinely valuable information and connections for others before you ever ask for something from them. Be an authentic and useful connection. Don’t give them a reason to say “no.”

If you continue to do good work and get noticed in the community, they will email you back eventually. When they do finally email you, just make sure to not respond. That’ll teach them.

More Guides You Will Love

6 Reasons Why You Shouldn’t Put a Price Tag on Your Startup Most of the things we shop for these days come with a sticker price. Even things we assume will have some room for negotiation–like cars and houses–usually come with a price tag. And so many entrepreneurs think they should pu...
The 5 Factors that Led Us to Victory at LAUNCH Techweek Chicago A few weeks ago, over 70 pre-qualified startups demoed their products and services for a chance to compete on Techweek’s main stage, for $100,000 is cash and prizes. Our startup, WeDeliver, won! Here are the five factors w...
How To Craft The World’s Greatest Elevator Pitch If there’s one thing I can do better than anyone, it’s sell something. I can sell you anything. In fact, just to prove that I can sell anything, a couple of years ago I got bored and sold empty plastic bags of “fresh Adironda...
Your Startup is Not First to Market. But Who Cares? All entrepreneurs have heard phrases like, “There’s already an app for that,” or, “X company already has first-mover advantage." When I did my first startup, I initially quivered whenever one of these phrases was mentioned, b...
Do You Have Enough Hustle to Build a Successful Startup? The typical digital startup has two founders: one is technical, the other does sales and marketing. Think of Hewlett and Packard of HP, Wozniak and Jobs of Apple, Evans and Maloney of GrubHub. My own company, Orbit Media, has...
Startup Institute: We’re Coming to Chicago! I'm really happy to share that we're building Startup Institute Chicago this Fall. Here's why. It's clear that Chicago is a special place for startups, and we want to make it the place for people to join them. When yo...
The 9 Golden Rules for Dealing With Bad Publicity Sometimes, bad publicity is inevitable. Even when you and your organization behave responsibly, you always run the small risk of an unexpected PR disaster. In the information age, bad publicity can reach the masses before you...
Should a Non-Technical Founder Learn to Code? "Should I teach myself to code today?" I could spend the next 2 years teaching myself a programming language, and I’d still be a more efficient marketer than coder. I know this, and that’s what continues to hold me back fr...
There’s No Such Thing As “Free” Funding for Your Startup Unless you are one of those entrepreneurs who has made a boatload of money for venture investors before, you have probably noticed that raising early stage venture capital is pretty challenging these days.  All the more so if...
Skinny Cows Many businesses want to generate a steady return of profits and keep their costs down.  So how can you become a cash cow while maintaining a lean startup business model? A cash cow is a business venture that generates posi...